This post is part of a series of posts on mindful eating. The Introduction contains links to the entire series.

Well, it’s the fourth day of my mindful eating trial and I’ve read thirty-eight pages of Jan Chozen Bays’ book. I like the book, but there are too many exercises for me to be able to do all of them. I’m picking exercises that are the most helpful.

Gywnn of Serene Journey has kindly volunteered to join me during the trial. I look forward to comparing experiences with him.

Even though it’s still early in the trial, I’ve learned about types of hunger and made some observations.

Types of Hunger

I’ve learned there are seven different types of hunger from the book:

  1. Eye hunger: You want to eat what you see. For instance, you may see a dessert tray in a restaurant and want the dessert even though you’re already stuffed. The beauty of the food entices you.
  2. Nose hunger: You smell something you want to eat. For example, you may walk into a bakery, smell something wonderful baking, and your mouth begins to salivate. Most of our sense of taste is related to smell. I’m sure you’ve experienced congestion from a bad cold and lost most of your sense of taste.
  3. Mouth hunger: You want to taste something and chew. Sometimes your mouth wants things that are crunchy or soft, hot or cold, salty or sweet, and so on. My favorite crunchy, cold, salty food is potato chips.
  4. Stomach hunger: You feel your stomach wants food because it feels empty or is gurgling. You may feel like your stomach is trying to digest itself.
  5. Mind hunger: You have thoughts of eating food. Your thoughts may begin with “I should” or “I shouldn’t”. For instance, you may think you should eat your green beans, but not more French fries.
  6. Heart hunger: You want certain types of food you find comforting. For instance, I’m comforted by chocolate - I want to eat it when I’m sad or anxious.
  7. Cellular hunger: You feel that the cells in your body want something. For example, if your body lacks certain vitamins, your cells may crave certain foods that contain those vitamins.

I did an exercise where I rated each type of hunger with a single dried cherry. It was an insightful experience - I could rate all types of hunger except cellular hunger. I don’t really understand how to sense cellular hunger yet.

I suggest you try mindful eating at least a few times – I think you’ll find it useful for understanding your hunger. When you want to eat, try to figure out which types of hunger motivate you. You can rate each hunger on a scale of one to ten before, during, and after the meal. Notice how your hunger changes.

Observations

I’ve made eight observations after a few days of mindful eating.

  1. I get bored with eating. The first few bites of a food are tasty. After that, the food becomes boring. It helps if the meal has a mixture of foods and I alternate bites of the different foods. My boredom may be why I like eating mindlessly.
  2. I’m eating less. I’m eating less during each meal without any effort. This may be related to my boredom, consciously tasting the food, or being more in touch with my hunger. I’m not sure.
  3. I find it difficult to evaluate the types of hunger. It all seems to be generic hunger, unless I really concentrate. This is a skill that probably takes time develop so that it becomes automatic. I’ll keep working on it.
  4. I’m more likely to eat food mindfully, if I prepare it mindfully. I have to prepare the food slowly to be mindful. I carefully look at each ingredient. I find this fun and interesting - it’s as if I’m seeing some foods for the first time.
  5. I can easily avoid external distractions. I just eat at the dining room table with nothing to read or do. This makes it easy to avoid external distractions, but I miss reading while I’m eating.
  6. I’m easily distracted by thoughts. I can focus on the food for a few minutes, but then my thoughts wonder and I have to consciously refocus. This may happen because I get bored with eating.
  7. I sometimes stay mindful after the meal. If I eat a meal mindfully, I’m more likely to continue to be mindful after the meal. This has only happened twice, but I hope it’ll happen more frequently in the future.
  8. I tense my body when I eat. This is weird. I tend to tense some of my upper body muscles whenever I take a bite of food. Even if I consciously relax after it happens, I usually tense again during the next bite.

Have you had any experience with the different types of hunger? Which types motivate you to eat?

Related posts:

  1. 30 Days of Mindful Eating – Day 14
  2. 30 Days of Mindful Eating – Day 30
  3. 30 Days of Mindful Eating – Day 22
  4. Your Mindful Eating Mission
  5. 30 Days of Mindful Eating – Author Interview

Tags: , ,

6 Responses to “30 Days of Mindful Eating – Day 4”

  1. Gwynn says:

    I find boredom sometimes happens with any mindful practice at first. There’s a bit of a withdrawal phase when you’re breaking out of the old habits — like your example of missing reading when eating. But by putting down the book you’re trading entertainment for being present.

    One way isn’t necessarily better than the other they just have different outcomes. Being mindful can lead you to eating less and enjoying food more but it may be boring. Reading provides entertainment but you may overeat.

    My observations:
    - It’s much harder to be mindful when eating with other people. You have to pay attention to the conversation and eat. I found I could be mindful for short periods but then would lose focus when listening or talking.

    - I ate a slightly burned toasted cheese sandwich. At the time being mindful wasn’t good because I really noticed that burned flavor. Because it wasn’t a good taste I stopped being mindful and just ate it. Thinking about it now, I think I should have continued to be mindful and really pay attention so that I could have fully observed what it was like. Oh well, with any luck I’ll be eating a burned sandwich soon enough! ;)

    So far so good. This is certainly proving to be a worthwhile experiment!

  2. Roger says:

    Gwynn,

    Thanks for your insights!

    Your observation about boredom makes sense. I’ll be interested to see what happens as I continue.

    I agree that eating with others makes mindfulness difficult. I try to wait for a lull in the conversation to take bites. I am trying to eat alone as much as possible during the trial.

  3. Hi Roger,

    So far so good with the mindful eating. I really trying to listen to what my body wants me to eat. Kind of a change for me because I think I eat what my brain tells me I should eat. Like for example, my body may crave chocolate but I figure I should be healthy and eat nuts instead. So this weekend, I craved chocolate. It was not due to emotions or stress but rather my body really wanted chocolate. So I bought a very small chocolate bar and ate the whole thing. It felt great…the craving went away. I enjoyed every bite. So it is kind of interesting to actually listen to one’s body. :)

  4. Roger says:

    Nadia,

    Like you, I sometimes crave chocolate!

    I think you are right - listening to your body is one of the best parts of mindful eating. I’m trying hard to listen to internal cues and ignore external cues - like time of day and pictures of food. I’m surprised how often my mind or heart wants something when my stomach is not hungry.

  5. What an interesting way to discuss mindful eating. I try to eat as mindful/intuitive as possible, but I really appreciate the breakdown of the different kinds of hunger. It’s so true. In an effort to research the psychology of our addictions to sugar (which is partially what my blog about) identifying different types of hunger could be one step closer to identifying WHY the addiction exists in the first place.
    Thanks for the fresh ideas.

  6. Roger says:

    my year without,

    You’re welcome! Sugar (in chocolate and ice cream) is one of my comfort foods. I read your blog and I’m impressed you have abstained from sugar for over a year.

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>